Crows Mill Sandwich Bread

By Micha

When we were growing up Nini and I had several calabash aunties. These women we called “Aunt XXX” were not related to us by blood, but they were definitely part of our family. I have fond memories of all of them. After all, it takes a village, right?

Aunt Becky was an especially close to me. She lived in a corn field outside Springfield with my mom and I when I was very young. Becky was on my team. I mean, heck, she used to finish my milk for me when my mom’s back was turned (according to my mom, though I’m not so sure, since Becky is actually lactose intolerant). As I grew up, we would visit her in Springfield during our summer “vacations.” My sister was even named after her (middle name).

I don’t see Aunt Becky very often anymore, but when we do get a chance to catch up (occasional stolen time while her kids draw on mirrors, longer than we have time for phone conversations) I am always reminded how much I love and admire her.

The year after Dylan and I got married Becky and Bob (her husband) gave us a beautiful handmade cutting board and several bread recipes as a Christmas gift. On the recipe card for this loaf she shared:

“Your mother and I met while working at a bar and restaurant called Crows Mill School. This is the bread I used to bake there when you were a baby. It’s a good, dense sandwich loaf.”

When I first started baking bread I tried making a good whole wheat loaf several times. Getting the loaves to rise was a true challenge for me, though I kept at it (even if sporadically).

This recipe rises up well and, while dense, is really a perfect solid sandwich loaf.

Crows Mill Sandwich Bread

  • 1 1/2 c lukewarm water
  • 1/4 c canola oil
  • 2 T honey
  • 2 T molasses
  • 2 1/2 c whole wheat flour, divided
  • 2 c bread flour, divided
  • 1/2 T instant yeast
  • 1.5 t salt

Start by mixing together all of the wet ingredients, the yeast, and 2 cups (1 of each) of the flour. Stir to evenly incorporate all of the ingredients. Let this mixture ferment at room temperature for 2-8 hours (or overnight in the fridge). When it’s ready to go you will see that it has developed a lot of bubbles and increased in size dramatically:

Stir your dough down and gradually mix in the salt (don’t forget the salt!). Begin to add the remaining flour. You may need to wait to use the dough hook on a mixer until you’ve gotten enough flour in for it to grab on. If you are kneading by had, just go for it.

Knead 5 minutes, let the dough rest 5 minutes, and then knead 5 more minutes. Place the dough in a well oiled bowl and turn to coat. Cover loosely (I just lay a plastic bag over the bowl) and let the dough rise in a draft-free environment (I like the microwave) until doubled in size, about 1 hour.

You will know when your dough is ready when a gentle poke leaves an indentation in the dough.

Roughly flatten your dough into a 8×12 inch rectangle on your counter. Really, don’t be a perfectionist about this. I never am and my loaves turn out fine. Fold into thirds, pinch the ends and place in a 2 lb loaf pan.

Preheat your oven to 350°. Allow your loaf to rise again until doubled in size, 45 minutes to an hour. Your dough will be ready when it just barely crests the upper lip of the bread pan, like this:

To get a shiny crust, use an egg wash (1 egg, 1 T water) on the top of the loaf. Slash the top of the dough cross-wise to allow steam to escape during baking. Place in the center of your oven and bake for 45-50 minutes, or until a tap on the top sounds hollow.

I’ll be sending this into Wild Yeast for this weeks YeastSpotting. Too good not to share.

Sandwich anyone?

Yes, this is a leftover turkey and cranberry sandwich with horseradish and cream cheese. Originally, I had intended to get this post done before Thanksgiving so you’d have a good loaf for your turkey sandwiches. Now you’ll have to be more creative. What’s in your favorite sandwich?

Tags: , , , , , ,

11 Responses to “Crows Mill Sandwich Bread”

  1. Heather Says:

    wow! that looks so light and delicious! i love homemade bread!! and a leftovers sandwich!? my favorite!

  2. toxobread Says:

    I’m a sucker for dense, perfectly solid sandwich loaves of bread.
    What’s in my favourite sandwich? Probably a slice of good cheese, tomatoes and fresh basil, all fitted snugly in between two generous slices of freshly baked homemade bread. Yum.
    Thanks for sharing your Aunt Becky’s recipe :)

  3. Kristen Says:

    That bread looks sooooo good. Love that photo! Add to that the sandwich ingredients and oh my…. YUM!

  4. Andrea Says:

    Lovely story! I’m sure Becky would be very proud of this beautiful loaf! It’s perfect!

  5. redmenace Says:

    I am absolutely going to try this!!!!! I am always looking for new bread recipes. Thanks!

  6. Susan/Wild Yeast Says:

    Absolutely too good not to share — thanks for sending it to YeastSpotting! My favorite sandwich might be a “BLT” with spinach instead of lettuce and soft goat cheese instead of mayo. On toast.

  7. katie Says:

    My favorite sandwhich is roasted veggie with goat cheese…mmmmm

  8. jenna @ foodwithkidappeal Says:

    oh that really inspires me to make bread at home. i started with dough again a couple weeks ago beginning a friday night home-made pizza night, and made ww crust. now i might have to bake my own sandwich bread too. my fav sandwich is chicken salad with fresh baby greens and sliced tomatoes.

  9. YeastSpotting December 5, 2008 | Wild Yeast Says:

    [...] Crows Mill Sandwich Bread [...]

  10. Sunshinemom Says:

    This post smells of Country warmth – lovely reading it made! I am making this pretty soon:) I would like a simple cucumber and tomato sandwich with some green chutney, thank you!

  11. All Know Mother Says:

    Thank you so much for that recipe, my entire family and me thank you, it’s excellent.
    I bake all the bread we eat, we do not buy bread at all and I use to try new ideas from time to time. Your bread looks so good I had to try it and it was a success.
    We live in Israel and have some hard period, we hope so much we can live in peace after these hard days of war.
    Thanks again!!

Leave a Reply